Saturday, September 17, 2011


Kansas defense short on scheme, talent

Kansas defender Tyler Patmon comes in to tackle Georgia Tech's Orwin Smith in the first half Saturday, Sept. 17, 2011 in Atlanta.

Kansas defender Tyler Patmon comes in to tackle Georgia Tech's Orwin Smith in the first half Saturday, Sept. 17, 2011 in Atlanta.


Podcast episode

Press Conferences & Post-Game Interviews

KU coach Turner Gill

Kansas coach Turner Gill talks to reporters following the Jayhawks' 66-24 loss to Georgia Tech on Sept. 17, 2011, in Atlanta.

Download podcast

Podcast episode

Press Conferences & Post-Game Interviews

KU defensive coordinator: 'What happened today is on Vic Shealy'

Kansas defensive coordinator Vic Shealy took responsibility for the defensive performance in his team's 66-24 loss to Georgia Tech on Sept. 17, 2011.

Download podcast

— The points Georgia Tech scored didn’t do justice to the more revealing indictment of Kansas University’s defense, which was the ease with which the Yellow Jackets scored them.

Never mind two-hand touch below the belt. If the rules had been one-hand touch anywhere, Tech still would have scored most of its touchdowns.

From Tech’s first play, a beautifully designed counter with a fake by quarterback Tevin Washington that sucked the entire defense in one direction so that running back Orwin Smith could sprint untouched for a 95-yard touchdown, the crowd of 42,025 in Bobby Dodd Stadium watched the home team lock up the front of KU’s defense and sprint away from the back of it with astonishing ease.

Early in the fourth quarter, the announcements noting school and ACC records started, and once they started they never stopped, much like the Tech offense.

The numbers looked like those compiled by eight-man football teams. Tech amassed 604 rushing yards and 768 total yards, averaged 41 yards per reception and averaged 13.5 yards on its 57 plays from scrimmage.

How did a team that lost a year ago to KU execute such a thoroughly humiliating payback? First, the longer players have been schooled by fourth-year Georgia Tech coach Paul Johnson, the more in sync with his unconventional offense they become. Also, the fewer players in the program who played for his predecessor, the better, because when not everybody follows the leader blindly, the whole isn’t always as great as the sum of its parts. Johnson’s word is gospel to all the players now.

The next ingredient in this perfect storm of a domination of KU’s defense had to do with emotion. The Yellow Jackets were embarrassed by last year’s loss and it showed.

Kansas defensive coordinator Vic Shealy threw himself onto the list of factors. Shealy said that the Jayhawks took pretty much the same approach against the run-oriented option offense as it did a year ago, when it was coordinated by retired Carl Torbush.

“That might, in effect, be the downfall of what we did because we got schemed,” Shealy said.

Johnson figured because what Kansas did a year ago worked, the Jayhawks would try it again. He figured right and ditched a couple of key menu items — veer-option schemes and a fullback-based dive, according to Shealy — and replaced them with a couple of others (a “Belly-G” and “Belly-G option,” Shealy said.)

“Completely counter to how we planned and we couldn’t get out of it,” Shealy said.

When KU did make adjustments, Johnson was introducing play-action passes that resulted in receivers galloping into the end zone untouched.

“Whenever your plan gets schemed, it comes back to me,” Shealy said. “What happened today is on Vic Shealy. I take responsibility for us.”

That’s the right thing for Shealy to say and in fact the game plan did play into Johnson’s hands, but no tactical approach would have resulted in a victory for a Kansas team that has serious defensive deficiencies.

The 3-4 defense does not have anyone in the front three that has shown the ability to shed blocks and get into the backfield. The two who had the best chance of doing so — Patrick Dorsey and John Williams (out for the season) — are injured.

So which is a bigger factor, the lack of production from the line or the lack of experience in the back of the defense? Tough to say because they are so linked together, but the secondary at least has a chance to improve.

“We would probably like to have a few more dynamic reactions out on the field to make some plays on the back end, the front end, and in the coach’s box, but we didn’t get it done,” Shealy said.

Kansas hasn’t been able to recruit a disruptive, get-off-the-ball-and-blow-into-the-backfield defensive tackle since James McClinton. He graduated high school in 2004. Georgia Tech’s offense doesn’t have anything to do with that.

“Sometimes we’d like to have a guy who’s a beast who can thrash guys out of the way and make some plays, sure,” said Shealy, before pointing to an area of hope. “We’re at a point athletically where we don’t look so slow chasing the ball. We’re getting in pace with the play, so we’re making some progress. Getting to the point where we can overcome being in a bad call, we’re not there yet, so as a coach, I’ve got to put us in a really good call every play.”

Shealy doesn’t buy that KU’s young defense doesn’t have any talented playmakers.

“I think Toben (Opurum) can make some plays. Steven Johnson can make some plays. Greg Brown had a couple of errors against Northern Illinois, but I still think Greg Brown can make some plays,” Shealy said. “I think Bradley McDougald can make some plays. Do we have some young guys who are struggling a little bit? Yes, but that’s one of the reasons why we didn’t try to do more in our plan this week.”

KU’s defensive coordinator said that Georgia Tech doing things so different from conventional offenses and in some cases so different from what it has done in the past was a factor in defensive players at times looking “frozen.”

“Fortunately, we don’t have to play a scheme like that (again this season),” Shealy said. “And hopefully Georgia Tech, Army and Air Force are not on the schedule the next few years.”

Not so fast. Syracuse and Pittsburgh are on their way to the ACC and Texas and Kansas could join them to form a 16-team conference. Oklahoma wants the Pac-12, but the Pac-12 doesn’t want Oklahoma State, so does that mean Oklahoma goes with its neighbor to the SEC? Or does it mean Oklahoma does the right thing Monday and decides to keep the Big 12 together?

Those questions are as difficult to answer as the riddle that is Georgia Tech’s offense.


Andy Tweedy 10 years, 4 months ago

I agreed with everything in this article until you say Oklahoma should do the "right thing" and keep the Big XII together. The Big XII is a mess, and OU should do whatever is in their best interest!

Jeff Kilgore 10 years, 4 months ago

Hey, rockchalk, take a look at the picture above? Is that a KU player? I don't remember one of our defenders ever being this close to a Tech player with the ball! Must have been my television. Tears do blur your vision.

Jack McEnaney 10 years, 4 months ago

Never in my life have I seen the option defended so poorly. If you are the defensive end going against the triple option is like a Christmas present. Guess what your job is? kick the crap out of the quarterback every single time he shows his face running around the end. Shed your block and make him sorry he showed up at the stadium! This is not hard! How many times do you think the quarterback can get drilled and keep wanting to run to your side. Bury him into the ground. Outside linebackers the same rule applies with the pitch back. Dont even look at the quarterback. Just go drill the running back without looking at the quarterback. Crush the running back. If the DE misses his assignment that is on him. For a team that is supposed to love playing together and trusts one another so much they looked clueless. The defense needs a complete overhaul. If Tx tech scores 40 on KU Shealy must be fired. The only place to go from here is use the bye week to work on shedding blocks and making tackles. We can not have our secondary stuck on blocks by wide receivers. I say open tryouts for every position on the defense Monday at three o clock. Lets see who wants to play.

Randy Bombardier 10 years, 4 months ago

I don't think you can say that. What we need is Gill and Co.s best recruitment effort on the D side of the ball for a couple of years. But I am going to be more critical of the D Coordinator. I agree with j43 above that this defense of the option did not look like they knew what they were doing. So, we never even got to see the best of our talent. I have been saying that we need an attacking defense and this was the game we should have seen that. I think it is possible that we need to get a seasoned D Coordinator. Bring someone who has seen it all. This Defense is not prepared.

texashawk10 10 years, 4 months ago

Before you go totally ripping on Shealy and the defense (I'm not excusing the performance today because that was an absolute embarassment), just remember that this defense is on its 5th DC in 6 years and has changed defensive alignments each of the past 4 years. That is the perfect recipe for a horrible defense. In 2007, Bill Young was the DC and they ran a 4-3. In 2008, Clint Bowen took over the defense and kept it the same, but in 2009 he changed the defense to a 4-2-5. Last year, Carl Torbush took over the defense and changed it back to a 4-3, but had to retire in May (after spring practice) so Vic Shealy takes over and changes schemes again to a 3-4 which KU was grossly undersized to do and implemented that defense at the start of fall practice after a depth chart from spring ball was finalized. I do have to question why Shealy would've changed defenses completely post spring, but I hope he gets the time at least give KU some stability with the DC and keep the same defensive scheme for more than a year because that's the only way the defense will ever show improvement.

Jayhawk1116 10 years, 4 months ago

An excellent point no one seems to think about. Well said.

Stephen Londerholm 10 years, 4 months ago

Yea the players played real bad and I saw a lot of quit in them which is unacceptable, but Vic Shealy is a terriable defensive coordinator. I don't understand why you would promote a guy from the secondary that was one of the worst parts of the defense last year I mean come on they gave up like 650 yards to Baylor who basicly threw just screen passes on them and he couldn't coach up his secondary all that game or for the rest of the year for that matter to stop just one play. Against GT lets blitz the corners and send the safetys out to cover the wideouts so that the man running down the middle of the defense can walk in. On the play before that when they got the false start it didn't work so lets run it again and give up a touchdown. And this article were he said they baited knowing we were gonna play them like last year and ran plays to trap them. Well you gave two plays just two plays that you said caused your entire defense to look like it couldn't stop a jr high team. Vic Shealy might be the worst coach ever and needs to FIRED, I mean come on Western Carolina and Middle Tenn put a better defensive performance than KU did and all the other games this year so far have been horrible defensive performances as well against bad teams. Thank God that our offense is real good because if they weren't we would be 0 and 3 getting beat by every team as bad as we did against GT I mean we controlled all the game every week by almost a 2 to 1 ratio and offenses still put up the numbers they have. The worst lost this year by far is Carl easily.

Ethan Berger 10 years, 4 months ago

what does basketball have to do with this?

Dan Pawlowski 10 years, 4 months ago

Well a free beer after each football game is hardly a punishment. It will just cost them a case per game.

troutsee 10 years, 4 months ago

jhawk 43 is right on the money. Also, GT really did not run the option that much and obviously KU D was not prepared for this departure from their usual style.

number1jayhawker 10 years, 4 months ago

And no one is buying your crap that you and your buddies keep spewing.

texashawk10 10 years, 4 months ago

The football team doesn't live in the Towers anymore (both basketball teams do) and the school finally started renovating those in 2008 and should be finishing the last building this year. A lot of the players now live off-campus so they can get a stipend for food which I believe is $30 a day or something like that. Considering the price for a meal plan comes out to $9 per meal (complete ripoff for the quality of food), that isn't a bad deal.

As for the FSU game, I believe the announcers said that was the first sellout in 4 years for the Seminoles which says a lot about the loyalty of that fanbase (not a good thing either). Unfortunately for building KU football, there just isn't the interest among the donors who have the money to actually make KU football relevant. If people like Philip Anschutz or David Booth decided to spend their money on football instead of other areas of the athletic department, they could easily outspend T. Boone down at OSU. I would love to see Anschutz design a new stadium for KU since he is the owner of AEG who also owns the Staples Center, the LA football stadium they are building downtown, and the O2 Arena in London. Anschutz is worth about 5X what T. Boone is worth and if KU could tap into his wealth, the possibilities for renovation of all the KU Athletics facilities would be endless. If KU is ever going to become a consistently good team in football, KU must convince people like Philip Anschutz and David Booth that it is worth their time and money to invest in the football team.

Jeff Coffman 10 years, 4 months ago

If Kavisko didn't have problems with one of his companies, I think we would have been further down these upgrades. Ultimately, we will see soem growth here. I think Anschutz and Booth will start coming to the table for some of the renovations, especially if that is a hold up for a new conference.

Dirk Medema 10 years, 4 months ago

Noticed the the crowd at Bobby Dowd was at most as big as in Lawrence. Maybe the facilities aren't quite as much an issue any more as they once were. Realistically, we're only one year into this regime. Some people think you just hit "defrost" to thaw out a 300# DL or 2, and suddenly everything is turned around. There were similar comments made a year ago about the O, but not so much this year when the OL is healthy and there are a few new playmakers.

Dan Pawlowski 10 years, 4 months ago

What more investments do you want? The workout facilities have been upgraded. The stadium has been upgraded. The only other thing left is the obvious, getting a coach that has proven he can play with the BCS big boys. But the problem with that is that no proven coach wants to start a program from the ground up. So you have to find the hungry coaches that want to build a legacy.

Jeff Coffman 10 years, 4 months ago

At $2MM per year, isn't HCTG one of the highest paid Coaches (like in the Top 20), that is what I didn't like about the hire. Is we could get a lot more with that kind of dough.

We're spending the money, we just aren't getting the results.

Clarence Haynes 10 years, 4 months ago

The stadium imo, leaves a lot to be desired( Great setting but the place looks like a big antique). Really needs to be spruced up: The track needs to go! The Gridiron Club needs to be reconstituted. A challenge!

Dan Pawlowski 10 years, 4 months ago

Spruce it up? Yea lets bring in Karl Lagerfeld while were at it.

Chris Bailey 10 years, 4 months ago

The plans to move the track and expand the seating capacity need to move forward. We need to add like 20-25K seats to the stadium. I realize we have a hard time selling the current stadium out but big conferences don't see it that way. They will see us having a large venue to hold contests in and generate dollars. That said we really need to focus on getting some JUCO D-linemen this year! We can't afford to grow our own talent from freshman. Yes we need to recruit some D-lineman as freshman but we really need some JUCO horses to help us compete now!

Dan Pawlowski 10 years, 4 months ago

Yes ,make an empty stadium appear even more empty. Good Idea.

Ian Legler 10 years, 4 months ago

For the money we are paying Gill I think we should just hire Jim Tressel. . . Then at least we'd have a coach who has proved he can recruit the best and beat the best.

Dan Pawlowski 10 years, 4 months ago

Yea, that way we can be just like the big boys...In hot water with the NCAA and waiting for sanctions.

georgepburdell 10 years, 4 months ago


First, I am a Georgia Tech alumnus and was at the game today. I listed to the KU defensive coach's audio after the game and he is a straight shooter and probably a good coach. I listed to part of the HC audio and there was a lot of tip toeing on his part and when it became obvious that he wasn't going to say anything worthwhile, I shut it down. As for your armchair defense, those Tech blockers had a say in the equation. Also, they did not run the pure option but two or three times. On the big plays that Tech had on offense, most of them were because Tech ran where your defenders weren't and the passes were generally completed with little interference from defensive backs. The receivers at Tech are excellent downfield blockers, too. Your offense had the ball for 75% of the first half. Had they been able to continue to keep Tech's offense on the sideline in the second half, things might have been different. I do not think Kansas wins, because the Tech guys wanted it more, but Kansas has some good players. Paul Johnson has been around a long time and has been successful for a long time. He outcoached KU. He outcoaches most everybody, though.

Jack McEnaney 10 years, 4 months ago

George, GT downfield blocking made the difference on play after play. My armchair defense is right on the money. Why does no one in the NFL run the option? Because their quarterbacks would die, and quarterbacks are the NFL. The GT offense did not employ the conventional option attack where it was only a quarterback pitch or keeper, however they did run out of the same basic formation with different options utilized. How many major college defenses force only one punt an entire game? They never got off the field. How can this defense have any self respect left? George, I am guessing you are a hell of an engineer right? If the parts of a machine dont work together( or at all) how can that machine move anywhere? The only way to win the game with the effort put forth by this defense was for the offense to score everytime. When exactly did anyone every believe that ok, here is where KU is going to stop them!?? Look at the drive summary. There was hardly any resistance whatsoever. Paul Johnson is a good coach but today came down to desire and preparation. The defense was not prepared. Also if Tex Tech comes out and runs plays to where our defense is not OH MY GOSH, WHAT DO WE DO?????? MAKE A STAND DEFENSE! HAVE SOME PRIDE AND BURY THEM INTO THE TURF.

Dan Pawlowski 10 years, 4 months ago

I don't believe a more true statement has ever been posted to this site.

Jeff Kilgore 10 years, 4 months ago

Yeah, the famous Paul Johnson with how many ACC championships and national championships? We know good coaches when we see them in the Big Eight/Twelve/Whatever.

Call me when he has Osborne or Switzer's number of championships. Until then, he's only your big fish in a little pond, and beating KU like a drum is not much to hang your hat on, helluva an engineer or not.

I do like Tech's team, though.

Jeff Coffman 10 years, 4 months ago

Do you plan on going on every team's website that you beat and writing stupid comments like this? Please KU isn't good and that was obvious, but really you are coming off a 6-7 team, and run one of the most archaic offenses out there. Just because KU can't defend it, doesn't mean that the likes of VT, FSU, Maryland, UNC, etc, won't stop you. Also KU is in the cellar of the Big XII this year, we knew it, I betcha about 7 teams in the Big XII would just crush you because they would get a good push at the line.

Sorry, but GT might have some playmakers, but what I learned from the game, is if we had one or two people that could actually shut down a player, GT would easily be stopped. Also, their defense actually allowed 17 points to KU in the first half, which shows your defense isn't quite as good as you hoped. They seldom put pressure on our QB, and they actually left gaps for the RB,

When you face a team that actually has an offense and defense don't expect it to be close. Enjoy this win while you can, but don't expect a BCS bowl.

Dirk Medema 10 years, 4 months ago

George - Thanks for the voice of reason. Seems pretty accurate to what I saw and heard. Sorry for the retorts. Sometimes it is just helpful to let peope vent.

Dan Pawlowski 10 years, 4 months ago

Voice of reason? Are you kidding me? Oh wait its dagger. I waste my incredulity.

bbritain 10 years, 4 months ago

terrible, bad defense, GA high schools play better. I am appalled by the performance today. Forget recruting this area....

Benjamin Piehler 10 years, 4 months ago

Alas, if only those GA high schools also taught grammar!

Lance Cheney 10 years, 4 months ago

I too am watching this OU-FSU game and they're just completely different players on these teams. They're physical specimens and FAST. Our guys are nowhere near this level. Kind of sad, but I'll keep supporting the Hawks!

johnnyhrdwd 10 years, 4 months ago

We'll get better, but njjayhawk is right about the investment, look at Oklahoma state.

greenworld 10 years, 4 months ago

Better get some juco transfers in here by next yr like Snyder does at Kstate. Looks like we are not playing for now with the players we have but rather playing for the future. TG - Its okay to yell at your team and get them mad at you. I have a feeling everybody got together for a moment of silence or prayer after the game it was that bad. He needs to get into some players azz, end of story.

Jeff Kilgore 10 years, 4 months ago

As much as I hate to write this, it's obvious to me that KU's defense will be the worst of all Division I teams this year in points allowed. If this is the last year of the XII, which it might not be, I would expect teams to kick poor teams down one last time. KU looks like that team. They don't break down to tackle, they don't pursue well, and all these things may be masked in comments in which the coaches take all the blame, but players play the game, and I don't see four true defenders on the field at any time for KU. These kids simply don't look like division one players, and that isn't something you can coach.

This season, despite the first two wins, can't get over soon enough. If Gill doesn't find some defenders, and if he doesn't grab some juco kids next year who can play, 2012 will be his last year.

I feel bad for him because he came here in a bad situation in which the talent was leaving, the kids were down, and his recruiting has not kept up. Sure, our offense has a bright future, and boy, and if this porous defense keeps taking the field, they'll be on the field all the time.

Did anyone else choke when they saw the statistic on TV that Tech's first five TDs came in an average of 80 seconds? I have watched football for nearly 50 years, and I cannot remember a game in high school, college, or the pros in which a team score on the first play of the first half and the first play of the second half. They scored on their first play three times. Akin to giving up three grand slams in one game!

This was a game reminiscent of the TT "meat necklace" game Pat Knight most famously confessed. Unless we perfect the onside kick, and unless we are prepared to play every series with four downs, we are doomed.

Dirk Medema 10 years, 4 months ago

There is a youtube of an AR HS fotball game from earlier this season that you would love. I think they have it linked on one of the daily list pages at One team scored 29 pts (?) without the other team even gaining possession of the ball. Opening possession, and 5 (?) straight on-side kicks. Gill would really be crucified if he tried anything even close to this.

squawkhawk 10 years, 4 months ago

Regarding the title...Master of the obvious!

Aaron Carpenter 10 years, 4 months ago

I'm not going to comment on the game, that spoke for itself. What really bothers me is the lack of adequate coverage not only by but also by the ljworld. What ever happened to the "gameday insert" in the the paper? Why is there no video coverage here on the website? I now that we are not a perennial top 10 team or even a top 25 team, but the coverage you provide is poor at best. As a BCS Conference school, I would imagine that every saturday provides you an opportunity to delve into cfb, and to give us, the fans, a look at the possible schemes, match ups and nuances for the week. You, however, choose not to do so, and thus robbing each and every KU fan, young or old, the coverage of their team they deserve. Most every other BCS school has a website, a newspaper much more in tune with the team than we do. It's hard to hope more from our team when the coverage you provide, your job, is done so poorly. Wake up, or leave, please.


"real" KU Fans

JacquesMerde 10 years, 4 months ago

Anyone missing Mangino, (sp.) you know the fat guy with the impossible name.

Kirk 10 years, 4 months ago

I miss having a competitive football team. If that helps answer your question.

jhox 10 years, 4 months ago

Vic Shealy is in the wrong line of work. Period.

I told a friend in week one that the defensive schemes looked to me to be more of a problem than the talent. Yesterday the talent didn't look up to snuff either.

Is Tharp injured? Benched? Playing and just being a complete non factor? He may be on the slow side, but at least he's a football player and a guy who can tackle if he gets his hands on someone. We were getting pushed around like rag dolls yesterday

I'm no X's and O's guru. I played a few years of high school football, and that's about it. But I've been watching football for 45+ years, and it seems to me that the best defenses are read and react defenses. When there is too much thinking going on, there are too many opportunies for mistakes. Maybe it is time dummy down the defense a little,and just let the kids play football? There is clearly a talent deficit, but not to the extent demonstrated in that game yesterday. I'm also not a fan of the 3-4 defense. I've not seen many teams run that defense with much success.

I watched the LSU-Mississippi State game Thursday night. Those defenses were moving around prior to the snap, faking blitzes...they were making the offenses think about them and what they were doing, almost more so than the other way around.

Dirk Medema 10 years, 4 months ago

Tharp got TRUCKED by the GT RB. One of the few times he was noticed.

Jeff Coffman 10 years, 4 months ago

I watched the OU, FSU, LSU, MSU, etc defenses and at the snap of the ball the line was pushing through the OL and forcing quick passes, pitches, or decisions. Quick decisions lead to turnovers as evident in both of those games. KU doesn't get a good push at the line of scrimmage and therefore slows the game down for the offense (of the other team). With time, good decisions are made. I think there was probably 1 play where KU forced a bad decision, which was a sack (which actually wasn't the worst decision that the QB could have made). If KU wants to improve they need to put 4 guys on the line and push the line back. This does a few things, cuts down runs up the middle, cuts down passing lanes, and forces the QB to make quicker decisions.

We aren't going to get Turnovers if we don't force their QB to react rather than execute.

Dirk Medema 10 years, 4 months ago

4 guys on the DL when we are already using 3rd & 4th string players/DT's? There's a reason they switched to a 3-4 even before we lost our 1st and 2nd string DT's. Going deeper into the abyss is not the answer to this team's problems.

Jeff Coffman 10 years, 4 months ago

I also don't think there has been enough criticism of the offense yesterday. With a run, run the wildcat, pass on "Chuck" third and long, we were actually lucky to be in the game as long as we were. There were some amazing catches that were made that kept our offense out there.

I was really surprised that everytime the wildcat was run, the guy that received it always ran with it, never once was it handed to another player, it was always a fake. If I picked up on that, I'm sure the DC of GT was all over that. Plus when you run the Wildcat if the player can pass and run it opens up more of the field. When we lined up in the wildcat, GT knew we were going to run, so they pushed 8 into the box, talk about tipping your hand.

Finally, could we get at least one halftime adjustment in any game? I've always judged coaches on what they do based on ingame and especially halftime adjustments.

Think about that, and now judge the KU coaching staff...your thoughts.

eastcoasthawk 10 years, 4 months ago

Paul Johnson flat out beat Vic Shealy like a drum yesterday. He's been doing it for years with this offense. He knows this offense better than anyone in the country so when he throws a curve and watches the reaction he is already a step ahead. Against Vic he seemed two steps ahead. He did it with a Navy team that always had undersized players competing with the big boys and went to more bowl games than KU did.

I can only hope that we look better against our conference opponents with known offenses than we looked against GT. That was as fugly as a game can get. And I know that Johnson pissed off a lot of people when he had a 4th and 3 and went for it with a 40 point lead.

Richard Heckler 10 years, 4 months ago

Maybe players will not want to play for Gill and his approach to their private lives?

Spending more money on stadiums is not what wins games..... it is the coaching staff and players. KU won games before people went nuts on spending. After all stadiums are such superficial objects.

Dirk Medema 10 years, 4 months ago

Were you one of the people predicting in the middle of last year, after the thrashings by BU & KSU, that all the good recruits would be decommitting? Hmmm, didn't exactly go down that way now did it? Maybe the players (and their parents) really do want to play for Coach Gill - as they have said.

Randy Bombardier 10 years, 4 months ago

It took me quite awhile to figure it out, the big difference between last year's game and this year. It was Carl Torbush. He left to fight for his life, Vic Shealy was promoted, and I suspect that the door is being left open for Torbush. He is the kind of guy we need who has seen it all. So, let's not be too hard. Unlike MM promoting Bowen after Bill Young left, we are in a different situation. Godspeed to Carl Torbush. May you get well soon!

John Percival 10 years, 4 months ago

Anyone who thinks the stadium is the cause of our losing has never been to Allen Fieldhouse. Bill Snyder did ok in the dump named after him. Faurot Field is half erector set. It's called coaching & players.

Dirk Medema 10 years, 4 months ago

Gill did a great job recruiting, and recruited D players. Unfortunately, we didn't get the DT committs we needed, but we did get a load of D players. It just takes longer to get a D player ready to contribute. And realistically, how many top programs have 3 & 4 players contributing as freshmen? What, you're telling me that it takes top programs time to develop non-5* players? Their fans must be outraged that a recruit is ready to contribute the moment they set foot on campus.

{sarcasm intended}

Leo Hawkins 10 years, 4 months ago

To heck with any BCS conference -- Pac 12 or Big East. We offer Nothing to a BCS conference. We are not a football school no matter how much we would like to spin it! We are who we are -- a middle of the road to mediocre football program with periodic success. Let's call it for what it is -- we are a Mountain West program masquerading as a big time program. We are more like Wyoming, New Mexico, SMU, and Air Force than Oklahoma, Texas, OSU, and MU (yes, MU!) than you think. If we could not capitalize after the Orange Bowl in '08, there is nothing that will. Mountain West, here we come!!!

Dirk Medema 10 years, 4 months ago

Maybe a coach that doesn't belittle his players and staff (so he can retain his coaches) can capitalize on the quality facilities and uni, then capitalize on an Orange Bowl victory.

Kirk 10 years, 4 months ago

This is the current experiment: Hire a nice guy.

How's it working out this time?

About the same way it worked out with yesterday's nice guys Val and Allen.

Next time, I'd recommend hiring a helluva good football coach, nice guy or not. (Usually they're not.)

Ryan Gerstner 10 years, 4 months ago

holy crap! How dumb is our coaching staff? The FIRST thing you'd ask yourself is if you were the other team's coach and your offense was slowed down the year before, how would you counter that? It's probably not too much of a reach to assume that GT probably wasn't going to do the exact same thing on offense again. For them to not be prepared for a different offensive attack at this level is unacceptable. Either get on the ball or go find another job.

squawkhawk 10 years, 4 months ago

Calm down hawkfan20. Don't you realize that this is on TG's second year. He's allowed to screw up and lose games.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.