Wednesday, May 9, 2018

Tom Keegan: Too early to bury Tall Ball in college basketball

Kansas forward Dedric Lawson (1) pulls down a rebound while running drills with the post players during an open practice on Tuesday, July 11, 2017. The Jayhawks are preparing for four early-August exhibition games in Italy.

Kansas forward Dedric Lawson (1) pulls down a rebound while running drills with the post players during an open practice on Tuesday, July 11, 2017. The Jayhawks are preparing for four early-August exhibition games in Italy.


Generally, danger lurks where fads flourish. Fads warp minds, blind fashion taste from born followers and stunt individualism.

Remember the Tamagotchi, the hand-held, digital pets that flew off the shelves late in the 20th century? It supposedly was marketed to children, but the inventors knew the true demographic of the consumers.

The Tamagotchi creators knew that helicopter parent whose need to control every aspect of a child’s life wasn’t quite sated, thanks to those unreasonable teachers who didn’t put extra and, in many cases, extra-large desks in classrooms so that parents could keep a constant eye on children.

So the helicopter parent gave a Tamagotchi for a birthday present as a means of exerting some sort of control over the child during school hours by either feeding or starving and definitely disciplining the digital pet.

Another pet fad had come into vogue during the 1975 Christmas season. Pet rocks, packaged in a cardboard box, sold for $4. The morons who bought them could have saved money by tilting their heads to the left, using their right palm to smack themselves hard on the right temple and then placing an open box under the left ear so that the rock could fall from one box into another.

Even sports, from time to time, fall prey to fads. In basketball, both NBA and college, 3-pointers are all the rage. Big men have embraced the little man’s equalizer shot as their own. Joel Embiid is far from the only NBA center who shoots them. Centers who don’t have shooting range beyond the 3-point arc have become the exception.

Copying the style of the up-tempo, 3-point shooting Golden State Warriors is in vogue for NBA and college teams.

Villanova won the national championship by having five 3-point shooters on the floor nearly at all times.

In the past two seasons, Kansas reached the Elite Eight and then the Final Four with a slender “power” forward and called it a four-guard lineup.

Coaches respect the 3-pointer, once considered the shot that gave the underdog a puncher's chance, more now than ever.

Villanova scored 40.2 percent of its points on 3-pointers, 15th-highest in the nation. Kansas and Villanova ranked 10th and 11th in the nation with a .401 3-point percentage.

So now, all college basketball talk that doesn't involve the FBI seems to center on the absolute need for every team to load up on 3-point marksmen, because it's not just the new way to win, it's the only way. Hello, does anybody's short-term memory still work?

Once upon a time, a team that scored just 25.3 percent of its points on 3-pointers (294th in the nation) and attempted just 30.3 percent (306th in the nation) of its field goals from 3-point range won the national title by defeating a team that scored just 26.6 percent (270th) of its points on 3s and attempted just 32.8 percent (258) of its field goals from long range.

How many decades ago do you suppose that prehistoric title game took place?

Try 2017, when North Carolina topped Gonzaga, 71-65.

Somehow, it took just one year for Tall Ball to become so yesterday. So make no mistake, Kansas is in big, big trouble.

The Jayhawks lost all of their 3-point shooters from the Final Four squad and haven't scored one in late recruiting.



By using four guards the past two seasons, KU coach Bill Self has shown he's willing to part from his preferred way of doing business, which means he's capable of going in the complete opposite direction in 2018-19, again parting from his comfort zone.

Self's preference always has been to play two big players and three guards, but if using three big men gives him his most talented starting five, don't think he's not capable of giving it a serious try.

In what seems like the unlikely event Silvio De Sousa plays for Kansas next season, why not go with a starting lineup of freshmen Devon Dotson and Quentin Grimes in the backcourt, 6-foot-9 Dedric Lawson at small forward, De Sousa at power forward and Udoka Azubuike, provided he doesn't keep his name in the NBA draft, at center.

If De Sousa can't play, using 6-8 K.J. Lawson at small forward and Dedric at power forward presents another option.

Sure, the Lawson brothers (not twins) both were far better rebounders than 3-point shooters during their sophomore seasons at Memphis. Dedric averaged 19.2 points, 9.9 rebounds and shot .270 from 3 in 2016-17 and K.J. averaged 12.3 points, and shot .328 from 3. It’s not what most college lineups look like, but there are advantages to putting so much size on the floor.

The most recent team to take an undefeated record into the NCAA tournament was even taller than that potential Kansas lineup. Kentucky’s 2014-15 squad had 6-10 Trey Lyels, a so-so 3-point shooter, at small forward. The Wildcats shot just .349 (143rd) from 3 and had the nation's best 3-point defense (.271). Kentucky had the tallest team in the nation, per, and didn't lose until Wisconsin, the second-tallest squad in the nation, scored a Final Four semifinal upset, 71-64.

Don't fall into the fad trap. Tall Ball is not dead, it's just not fashionable.


Craig Carson 1 year, 5 months ago

tall ball can work BUT, you still need at least 1 or 2 guys that can hit 3s at a respectable rate..ya gotta keep the defense honest..if every guard shoots 3's like Garrett did last season then teams will just pack the paint and force KU to hits 3'S..WVU beat UK in 2010 E8 by doing just that..this could be the worst outside shooting team since Selfs 1st squad in 2004..Miles/Langford/Giddens didnt exactly scorch the nets that year

Craig Carson 1 year, 5 months ago

and for the record, I can wait for KU to get back to playing grown man basketball..boring watching KU shoot 30 3's a game...If Dok comes back, the lack of 3pt shooting won be as alarming..bad enough we wont have Silvio..Ill take a frontcourt of Dok, Dedric and McCormack over any of the previous front courts KU has had these last 6 years..our last true front court was TROB and Withey

Lawrence McGlinn 1 year, 5 months ago

2017 was actually kind of an outlier. Villanova in 2016 and UConn in 2014 had very limited inside guys. The three has gotten much more prevalent over the thirty years or so it has been in college b-ball. And it is not a coincidence that a KU team that had serious doubts early in the year was able to make the final four by shooting the three well. Aesthetically I prefer a faster, more open game where the ball moves until an open three becomes available. Dumping it down to a big guy every time down the court who then looks around, holds it, maybe pushes a smaller guy closer to the basket then flicks it toward the rim is boring to me.

Craig Carson 1 year, 5 months ago

I see what you are trying to say, but remember, that same KU team lost to Oregon because they didnt have an inside game to turn to when the 3 ball didnt fall and this seasons FF, Silvio and Dok were extremely effective.KU shot the 3 ball well, but without Dok and Silvio they dont win the BIG 12 or make the FF..Ill take boring if it means winning another NC..all that fun and gun is a thing of beauty until the shots dont fall..then you'll wish you had some big men that can get buckets in the paint..Golden State hasnt changed the NBA..teams are gonna be hard pressed to find 5 starters who can all hit 40% from 3..its a fad

Gary McCullough 1 year, 5 months ago

With taller player inside to protect the rim, guards aren't as concerned about being beaten off the dribble. Remember how Withey was able to swat away what looked like easy layups? So guards need to run the 3-pt shooters off the line. The greatest flaw of last years team was rebounding. We had to use guards to supplement rebounding. Three-point shots are great, but should be balanced with solid defense.

Jay Scott 1 year, 5 months ago

Every matchup creates advantages AND disadvantages. 3 guards, 4 guards, taller, quicker...whatever.

In the end, the best players and coach win.

Dirk Medema 1 year, 5 months ago

The truth that helped the tall U.K. team and hurt us was the ability or not to defend the 3. GSW is in part so good because their 5 can both shoot from and defend the perimeter. Dok doesn't need to develop a 3 pt shot (FTs would be nice) but he will need to be able to defend it. That is even more so the case for the next level.

As good as the Withey-Robinson front court was, there were games when Withey sat a lot because TRob couldn't defend the perimeter (See Purdue).

Commenting has been disabled for this item.