Monday, January 21, 2013


Opinion: Weber great hire for K-State

Kansas State coach Bruce Weber gestures to players during the second half of a game against Oklahoma State Saturday, Jan. 5, 2013, in Manhattan.

Kansas State coach Bruce Weber gestures to players during the second half of a game against Oklahoma State Saturday, Jan. 5, 2013, in Manhattan.


The stench from the cyber stink bomb that exploded when Kansas State athletic director John Currie hired Bruce Weber didn’t deter the school’s ministers of sports propaganda from doing their jobs.

They needed to line up quotes from prominent college basketball names to promote the hire, and they had plenty of places to turn for help.

The first man quoted was an easy choice. Gene Keady, five-time Big Ten coach of the Year when he was at Purdue, was Weber’s chief mentor. A former K-State football player, Keady recommended Weber highly for the job in the wake of his firing by Illinois nine seasons after hiring him.

Keady, now an assistant to former understudy Steve Lavin at St. John’s, called Weber “one of the top five coaches in the nation.”

Michigan State’s Tom Izzo said: “He’s beat me and my team more often than not. I’ve recruited against him and lost, and I’ve recruited against him and won, and (it) hasn’t changed things.”

North Carolina coach Roy Williams, who always will keep one eye trained on college basketball news in the state of Kansas, said: “Bruce is an absolutely fantastic hire for Kansas State. Frank Martin did a great job following Bob Huggins, and I feel that Bruce will do a great job following Frank. They have some very good players there, tremendous enthusiasm and fan support.”

ESPN analyst Jay Bilas, who doesn’t spin when he talks, called Weber “a great hire” and “outstanding basketball coach.”

No point in trying to dispute any of those opinions. An upset against Kansas in Bramlage Coliseum tonight would vault Weber into the driver’s seat for national Coach of the Year honors.

Kansas State enters the game ranked 11th in the nation with a 15-2 record and an eight-game winning streak that coincides with Weber’s shift to a four-guard starting lineup. The coach has come a long way in a short time with the Kansas State fan base.

An exhausted Weber didn’t do himself any favors at his introductory news conference. When reeling off the names of famous former coaches, Weber stumbled through Cotton Fitzsimmons, first calling him “Fitzgerald.” Then he referred to Mr. K-State, Ernie Barrett, as “Ernie Barnett.”

Big deal. All those local references coaches and administrators make when formally saying hello come off as forced anyway. It all comes down to winning. Weber’s start has enabled Currie’s seat, which heated up when it became obvious Martin’s departure at least in part was caused by a poor relationship with his boss, to grow so much cooler.

Already, Weber looks like the perfect hire at the perfect time.

In one monster recruiting season, Bob Huggins brought big-time basketball back to Manhattan. Martin advanced it. And Weber, a better teacher of offensive X’s and O’s than Martin, has a chance to move the program forward.

Especially considering Missouri’s departure from the Big 12, the more progress Kansas State makes in basketball, the better it is for the KU basketball program. As Huggins said during his short stay in Manhattan, a rivalry isn’t truly a rivalry unless both teams win some games. Tough tests, especially in rivalries, strengthen teams.

K-State fans didn’t appreciate how quickly Huggins bolted for his alma mater, West Virginia, but became grateful to him for leaving behind Martin, his top assistant.

Martin’s winning ways, broad shoulders and bug-eyed glare all combined to make him a revered figure with Kansas State’s colorful student section and wealthy alumni alike. Currie couldn’t run the risk of hiring a coach who might be intimidated by the shadow of Martin’s popularity.

Replacing a well-liked coach was nothing new for Weber, who has been dogged for years with criticism over his decision to hold a mock funeral for Illinois predecessor Bill Self in practice during his first year on the job.

“I had been through a similar transition not only at Illinois, but at Southern Illinois and even as a young assistant at Purdue when coach Keady took over after Lee Rose had been to the Final Four,” Weber said Monday.

K-State’s new coach won 10 NCAA Tournament games in a five-year stretch. The first two years of that span came at Southern Illinois, so Weber did it with more than just Self’s recruits. The man can coach. If he can recruit at a high enough level, he’ll be mentioned prominently in discussions as to the second-best coach in the Big 12, and the state’s basketball rivalry will be better for it.


Jeff Coffman 7 years, 1 month ago

First, caught off guard with that tonight reference...we play on Tuesday.

Second, Weber is a good fit for K-State, but the 4-guard is a gimmick when you are underskilled and are trying to create match-up issues. It works a lot because not a lot of teams are used to playing that style. You have to have guards with length and agile feet from your 3-4 positions. KU should actually do pretty good with this, or send NT out there and bench Young...seemed to work last game.

Three, longterm K-State might continue to struggle, it just seems like a tough place to get recruits and the small amount of success wasn't as deep as some people would have hoped.

Finally, Wiggins did a lot for K-State, and Martin road those coattails for a while. He was smart to leave when he did, he would have had a poor year this year.

KJD 7 years, 1 month ago

I do have some thoughts I can not resist sharing about a 4-guard line up as being a 'gimmick'. My first thought was the number of college level programs who would be psyched to have one big on their roster who had strong big man skills–if our standard is going to be the kind of skill the bigs that KU is fortunate to be regularly loaded with on our rosters.

Then the recent Villanova teams with Scottie Reynolds come to mind and they had great success in the Big East during his time, went to a Final Four, and when we beat them in the Sweet 16 in 2008 they were smaller in the post, though still skilled and successful as a team. To the credit of your perspective we handled them fairly easily for such a big game due to our size advantage in the front court. Sasha tore them up. What do you do when you don't have a senior like Sasha on your bench, or even as your best big on the roster?

Marquette in recent years has developed similar kind of teams with great success in a challenging Big East conference. There are so many teams that play smaller, and does help to have power, yet sometimes you have to play a bigger guy with guard skills at the 4 when the team develops and shapes up.

Richard Scott 6'6" for KU made us small yet that man could score smoothly over 7 footers in the low post and board with the best of them. He was truly a forward yet it is a good example of how you can be small and play big. Releford does it. White III has already shown a knack for grabbing boards. My all time favorite to do it well is Hinrich who was a true point, played small forward on a Final Four team and could get into the paint to get nasty on scratching out boards. (Roy beats Calipari)

The last thought to offer on this idea of 'gimmick' to play small is to expand on something I noted this weekend after the game. One of Self's favorite Final Four teams that he has seen was the 1989 Illinois Final Four team. To repeat, Self said he liked them because they had a bunch of 6'5" that could switch every screen. That one comment of his has fueled a bunch of thoughts on the way this team is coming together as I watch them develop. That Illinois squad, after looking it up to see the personel, was called the "Flyin' Illini" and they had Kendall Gill 6'5", Nick Anderson 6'6", Kenny Battle 6'6", four year starter Stephen Bardo 6'5" and Marcus Liberty 6'8".

The smaller line up is an interesting development for this years team in my mind due to the regular commentary of Bill Self on how our rotation at the 4 spot is playing out this season. It's talented, it has depth if you look at if from the style of play that the '89 Illinois team played, and it is really young and lacking in experience if you exclude Kevin Young.

KJD 7 years, 1 month ago

To emphasize, I'm not disagreeing with you at all except for thinking that it happens a lot more frequently than the way I'm reading you. I just see it as there are a lot more talented guards and guys in the world who can play that are under or around 6' 6" (in sneakers 6' 7" which can always be rounded up to 6'8" if they have a long wing span) than talented true big men so it is a regular condition that coaches find themselves. Smaller line ups can be really good and successful at this level.

Sandeep Kalburgie 7 years, 1 month ago

FYI - The game's not tonight. Its tomorrow!!

Boouk 7 years, 1 month ago

It was easy to predict that KSU would have a smooth transition from Martin to Weber. If Weber recruits well, KSU will be good for as long as he's there.

Brianna Zaleski 7 years, 1 month ago

I hope that BW does turn out to be a good hire. The worry I have with him is recruiting. He can obviously coach (he took Self's recruits to the NC game and now has Frank Martins recruits playing well) I just wonder if he can bring in big time DI talent

AirCapJay 7 years, 1 month ago

I think that will be tonight's score as well: KU 73, KSU 59.

Michael Leiker 7 years, 1 month ago

Agree completely with how important it is for KU to have KSU competitive. Thanks for making this point.

Steve Jacob 7 years, 1 month ago

Weber is a great coach, with someone elses players. He was a bad recruiter at Illinois.

And "In one monster recruiting season, Bob Huggins brought big-time basketball back to Manhattan" was funny, because Michael Beasley was sent to KSU by an agent, and paid all the rent and car payment for him and his mom. Beasley said this in court records, so I have no idea why KSU is not under investigation.

KJD 7 years, 1 month ago

Great read. A ton of good info and perspective.

My K-State/Big XII buddy will enjoy this–except for the second best coach part ;-) I know my buddy is steadily simmering up for the big game tomorrow, which usually starts off as quiet confidence or hope to play well and by game time he wants to see KU be broken, destroyed, thrashed. Then a few days later, win or lose, football or basketball, he settles down.

My buddy seemed so relieved about the Weber hire when they beat Florida which was an important win to kick off Weber's coaching tenure. He had mixed feelings about the hire due to the mixed track record at Illinois. A bunch of these comments stem from that period and I have got to think Weber only grew and matured even more as a head basketball coach to help him in his new tenure. Beating the Gators had to be a confidence builder for the team and that colorful student section. They do create a fantastic environment when we visit. It's always sweet to win there.

The fact that Weber and his crew got this team to switch over to a whole new set of offensive principles in their first year to create this matchup between two teams undefeated in conference, one ranked #11/13 and the other #3/2, is just another compliment to the coaching ability.

It's on the defensive end that I'm very curious about for the remainder of the season and well into the future. Great coaches like we've had here at KU coach it up on both ends of the court. Weber had to be grateful for the basketball culture that Martin established on the Defensive end. On Weber's bench he is reunited with Chris Lowery.

I will always remember Chris Lowery as the coach who put that Defensive juggernaut together at Southern Illinois in 2006-2007. That team knew how to play D for 40 minutes. The Saluki's relentlessly attacked us in the Sweet 16 on the Defensive end, just like Martin's teams would at K-State.

To digress a little bit, but not much, is to think about how huge it is to win a Sweet 16 game. I thought KU looked a bit sluggish against UCLA in the 2007 Elite Eight and, from my perspective, I always have given the credit for that to Lowery's crew. That 2007 KU team showed their mettle and won that Sweet 16 game. They absolutely had to pour all of their effort to survive that game which could have gone either way. I still think that winning that Sweet 16 game in 2007 helped build the mettle of that 2008 team to go all the way. To win that Final Four in 2008 took a lot of toughness, it was loaded with four outstanding 1 seeds. It's the same way I think of that 2001 KU team that played Self's Illinois team in the Sweet 16 which had the Jayhawk's ready for Self and Illinois in 2002 in the Sweet 16.

I'm totally with Keegan on this one. K-State is going to be really good under Weber and company. K-State fans might have had to ease into it, though they are feeling real good right now and this years team has lot's of upside. They match up with KU really well.

Geezer 7 years, 1 month ago

Weber is an idiot. Listen to what the ILLinois fanbase has to say about him after suffering through 9 seasons of that crap.

jhkprd 7 years, 1 month ago

jhawkrulz, who is "Wiggins?" I know you meant Huggins, but how can we forget Huggy Bear? Illinois fans have always reminded me of Misery fans, with illusions that that somehow they are elite and should get the best coaches and battle for the league and national titles. They were fortunate to get BS on his way up, and Weber did a pretty good job for them for several years. IMO, Weber is the type of coach that fits well with KState, smart, steady, and understated, not an overly-emotional hot dog who will always look for the bigger stage. Don't be surprised when KState hold serve against us, if not this year, in the next two or three.

jaybate 7 years, 1 month ago

Weber built down Illinois.

Building down does not usually make a desirable candidate.

Would KU have hired Self if he had built down Illinois?

Would Illinois have hired Self had he built down Tulsa?

KSU apparently likes hiring troubled coaches. They hired Huggins on the rebound from a melt down at UCinn. Now they have hired Weber after a conflicted end at Illinois.

There is no doubt such men know how to coach. The problem is their personalities appear not conducive appear to building up a program. Huggins did well with Behlein's material for few years at WVU, but he is building them down now. Weber seems likely to repeat his Illini experience at KSU--a harder place to recruit to.

jhox 7 years, 1 month ago

Jaybate, K State has a problem. They are located in Manhattan, KS. It's not like they have great coaching candidates beating on their door wanting to come there.

jaybate 7 years, 1 month ago


I'd like to agree with you, because I am particularly cheerful today, but...

Coaching is a profession. There are 347 Division 1 schools with basketball teams. Probably only a third of those, 100, are majors. KSU is a major. Of that 100, only 20 have the kind of basketball tradition that Kansas State has.

Basketball coaching at such a school is a highly desirable job. I would take in an instant. I would take Baylor's job in an instant, and I can't stand Waco, or Texas. Professionals go where the work is.

As of December, 2012, there were about 155 million persons in the civilian labor force. I feel confident that there will always be 20 above average coaching candidates looking to coach at a D1 major with basketball tradition and an arena that is filled for every game.

And I do not believe these candidates have to have just left conflicted situations before.

The President and AD at KSU seem to lack much self-confidence and insight about hiring coaches. It seems pretty clear to me that neither man would ever have hired Roy Williams to coach at KSU, when KU hired Roy Williams. They don't trust themselves to know who would be a good basketball coach and who would not.

Look at their recent hires. They hired Bob Huggins, a troubled coach, apparently because he flashed Beasley at them. He bolted.

Next they hired Frank Martin, a coach with a troubled background, and a coach needing anger management training, apparently because Dalonte would stay with Martin and Dalonte was flashing some players at them. It was just dumb luck that Martin turned out to grow as a coach.

jaybate 7 years, 1 month ago

Now, they have hired Bruce Weber based on the word of an old KSU grad and retired Purdue coach Gene Keady.

Consider their reliance on Keady, as a counselor. He is a good coach, not a great one. He never got deeper than the Elite Eight He basically won at a 2 of 3 games he coached. He did it at a good basketball school in the Big Ten, which says quite a bit about Keady's acumen. He is qualified to give good, not great advice.

But then consider the kind of advice he gave KSU. Hire my old assistant and pal for 20 years, who just built down Illinois from the high level it achieved after Kruger and Self built it up. Hire my old pal who got into such a conflicted situation at Illinois that they let him go even when he was still winning about 20 games per season.

Yes, he got some positives from Tom Izzo and Jay Bilas. But what are they going to say? Look, he's a good coach, and forget he's a whiner that generates conflict?

KSU is convinced it needs a name with access to a recruiting ground like Illinois.

I suppose they are right to some extent.

But what they really need is a coach with some charisma that knows how to coach and recruit and build a program for the long term.

There are quite a few assistant coaches ready to assume the reigns around the country. There are quite a few head coaches at mid majors ready to assume the reigns.

I just think they could have (and should have) done better.

You think not.

We agree to disagree.

jhox 7 years, 1 month ago

You bring up good points, but picture Manhattan, KS in your mind for a moment. I won't even comment on the female scenery over there (well, maybe I inadvertently just did.)

Bottom line, it is not the kind of place where a big city kid wants to go to school, unless they have few options. Huggins brought in some studs, but he wasn't under NCAA jurisdiction while recruiting those guys. Martin had a few connections that helped him, but that was not going to be sustainable.

KUsmoothies 7 years, 1 month ago

Always one reason I've been so impressed w/ Snyder. Manhattan, KS cannot be an easy sell to top recruits

Steve Reigle 7 years, 1 month ago

" If he can recruit at a high enough level." That's the key. He has not proven his ability to recruit enough top recruits. So far, at Illinois he did well until he ran out of Self's recruits. So far, at KSU he's doing well with Martin's recruits. Only time will tell whether he can recruit well enough to maintain success at K-State. X's and O's are important but if the recruiting doesn't match it, then the result is failure. Again. He did, after all, get fired from his last job because of failing to maintain the performance standard set by his predecessor. For K-State's sake, and that of the Big12, I hope he proves me wrong and does well. But doubts will linger here for a few years, at least.

Steve Gantz 7 years, 1 month ago

I told this story over on another thread, but it's worth repeating.

Webers brother was the high school coach of John Scheyer who starred at Duke for four years. He was an awesome high school player and recruited by everyone including Weber. Weber couldn't get a kid to come to Illinois even when his brother was his HS coach. Does that tell you something about Weber?

A lot of talent left the state while Weber coached there, including of course Sherron Collins. Players in Illinois didn't want to play for him. Self of course recuited NBA talent to that school, Deron WIlliams, Luther Head most notably. But once those guys left, it was slim pickins!

My impression of Weber, and I've followed the Illini for 3 decades, is that he was a nice guy, but really struggled with inspiring his players to go all out for the U. I thought he was a great hire by virtue of his success at SIU, but several seasons of unispiring play later I have little doubt that KState made a mistake.

Jeremy Paul 7 years, 1 month ago

That is very interesting about Scheyer. You know, I think when coaches get to this level, there is very little separation between their talents as "x's and o's" guys. Basically, they ALL pretty much know what they're doing. But the thing that makes a great coach is the ability to build a team. The ability to take 12-15 men and motivate them and inspire them to play hard for each other and love each other and go to battle with each other. I think we all know Self is great at that. And it seems Weber has no clue.

jhox 7 years, 1 month ago

Great coaches all seem to have one unique trait. They are very demanding but, at the same time, well liked and respected by the players. That's a unique personality trait that not a lot of guys have. They yell and scream at a guy one second, but know the right time to put an arm around him and tell him good job.

One of the things I've noticed about Coach Self, he'll yell and scream and get on guys the entire game, but in a tight game, in the last minute or two, he's all smiles, relaxing the guys, building thier confidence up rather than tearing it down.

Geezer 7 years, 1 month ago

KU hires coaches that succeed at Illinois. KSU hires coaches that fail at Illinois.

stm62 7 years, 1 month ago

I like the basketball "rivalry" just fine the way it is. It's so SWEET to beat the purple kitties because they HATE us so much. I remember a time, decades ago during the Owens-Hartman era, that this was a true b-ball rivalry. I did not like it near as much.

jayhawkinATL 7 years, 1 month ago

I agree with what some have already posted...the game is close ONLY if KU allows KSU to dictate the pace and make it an ugly game.

riverdrifter 7 years, 1 month ago

That's exactly what they will try to do.

AirCapJay 7 years, 1 month ago

KU every year seems to go through a spell where they play ugly and look so over-rated. I hope the hype of this game will get the guys back on track playing like they did against Ohio State.

actorman 7 years, 1 month ago

Actually, it won't really reflect that poorly even on the SEC. It's not like Haith is being investigated for things he's done at Misuse ...

Jonathan Allison 7 years, 1 month ago

It would have been kinda fun to play them this year in AFH just to get the opportunity to heckle.

I remember the Kansas centerfolds when that Duke greaseball Quin Snyder was on the hotseat before they hired Mike Anderson.

They featured Donald Trump with his signature line "You're Fired!"

jhox 7 years, 1 month ago

He underachieved recruiting with some of the best talent in the country in his own back yard (Chicago) so what chance does he have recruiting to Manhattan? It was an OK short term hire but a horrible long term hire. He's good at X's and O's but once Martins players are gone, he'll soon be gone.

pizzashuttle 7 years, 1 month ago

This comment was removed by the site staff for violation of the usage agreement.

riverdrifter 7 years, 1 month ago

EJ must not go 1-11 from the field with 2 assists if KU is to win.

namohcan_99 7 years, 1 month ago

Bruce Weber is a loser. He looked pretty good at Illinois the first season or two with Bill's kids. Same thing goes here with Martin's kids. Once those seniors graduate this year, Weber is going to be that loser again. His best work was in the mid-majors and worked well at Southern Illinois. But that's a much less competitive conference than the Big XII. Frank Martin was a great hire for K-State and they really lost out when they lost him.

DanR 7 years, 1 month ago

Bruce Weber... nice guy, but just another branch of dead wood from the Gene Keady coaching tree. (Illinois should have known better)

jayhawks1009 7 years, 1 month ago

When you win at Illinois, you get the Kansas job. When you lose at Illinois, you get the Kansas State job.

actorman 7 years, 1 month ago

When will he be holding the funeral for Frank Martin, and will anyone here be attending?

actorman 7 years, 1 month ago

Does anyone have an extra ticket for the home game against KSU on 2/10? If so, please message me.

FearlessJayhawk 7 years, 1 month ago

He was a great hire for this year and maybe next, but he will probably go on the same slide he did at Illinois.

archercc 7 years, 1 month ago

Haith last year and Wbber this year? Since when is going into a program that has had success, inheriting the same players who danced last year and not taking a complete nosedive make you a candidate "coach of the year?"

Steve Quatrocky 7 years, 1 month ago

I hope tomorrow morning all the KSU fans are complaining that he was a bad hire.

Jim Stauffer 7 years, 1 month ago

No one should decide Self or Weber's future over this game. If Weber wins does that mean he is better than Self? Of course not.

If Weber has shortcomings as a coach they are recruiting and coaching tough defense. As long as he has his old assistant from SIU, he will coach tough D but if that guy every leaves it will be Illinois all over again.

Tony Bandle 7 years, 1 month ago

Just two comments about tonight's game..Kansas RPI 3, Kansas State RPI 31.....Kansas vs Kansas State, 183 - 91, the third largest victory total in NCAA history of one school over another!!

nostradavid 7 years, 1 month ago

"An upset against Kansas in Bramlage Coliseum tonight..."

big IF

Brandon Pope 7 years, 1 month ago

Bruce embodies inferiority to Bill Self. Kansas state is inferior to KU. So yes, he seems like the perfect fit to carry that legacy forward.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.